On One Approach to Assessing the Efficiency of Inspection and Control Activities


The problem is reviewed concerning the efficiency of inspection control activities assessment. The importance of using a risk-oriented approach for the transition to proactive methods of ensuring the production safety of hazardous production facilities is noted. It is concluded that it is necessary to develop the basic model in terms of using the value of prevented damage as one of the efficiency indicators. The analysis is made concerning the scientific publications from the point of view of the possibility and feasibility of using the Heinrich-Berd pyramid when justifying activities on ensuring industrial safety. The examples of using this approach in solving various practical tasks is given in the article. A methodological approach is proposed related to the assessment of prevented damage as one of the indicators of the efficiency of inspection control activities using the methodology of building the Heinrich-Berd pyramid. In addition to the existing 4-level classification of events in the field of industrial safety, it is recommended to introduce level 5 related to the identification of inconsistencies identified as the result of inspection and control activities. Identified inconsistencies are prerequisites for the events of level 4 of classification. It is assumed that the elimination of the identified inconsistencies (level 5) can potentially lead to the prevention of events at levels 1–4. The formula is proposed for calculating the prevented damage (direct and indirect) considering the ratio between the events of different levels and the level of elimination of the identified inconsistencies. Estimated calculations of the total prevented damage to the hazardous production facilities in the gas industry were performed. The calculations showed the adequacy and practical significance of the proposed approach. This approach, of course, requires testing and confirmation of the assumptions made, but in general shows that the value of the prevented damage can be estimated and used as one of the indicators of the efficiency of the inspection and control activities. 

1. Lukyanchikov M.I., Lesnykh V.V., Nemchin Yu.V., Bochkov A.V. On Specificities of Risk-Oriented Approach in Organizing Particular Types of Inspection and Control Activities in PJSC Gazprom. Gazovaya promyshlennost = Gas Industry. 2020. № 1 (795). pp. 106–115. (In Russ.).
2. Heinrich H.W. Industrial accident prevention: A Scientific Approach. 4th ed.: N.Y.: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1959.
3. The Heinrich/Bird safety pyramid — Pioneering research has become a safety myth. Available at: https://risk-engineering.org/concept/Heinrich-Bird-accident-pyramid (accessed: April 27, 2020).
4. Hale A. Conditions of occurrence of major and minor accidents: Urban myths, deviations and accident scenario's. Tijdschrift voor toegepaste Arbowetenschap. 2002. 15 (3). pp. 34–41.
5. Bellamy L.J., Ale B.J.M., Whiston J.Y., Mud M.L., Baksteen H., Hale A.R., Papazoglou I.A., Bloemhoff A., Damen M., Oh. J.I.H. The Software Tool Storybuilder and the Analysis of the Horrible Stories of Occupational Accidents. Safety Science. 2008. 46 (2). pp. 186–197.
6. Gilbert C., Journé B., Laroche H., Bieder C. Safety Cultures, Safety Models. Taking Stock and Moving Forward. Cham: Springer Open, 2018. 166 p.
7. Tishanin A.G., Lapidus V.A., Kopysov O.A., Usoltsev A.N. Safety management methodology based on the Heinrich pyramid. Metody menedzhmenta kachestva = Methods of Quality Management. 2011. № 11. pp. 4–9. (In Russ.).
8. Lakin I.K., Abolmasov A.A., Melnikov V.A. Risk Management Model to Prevent Locomotive Malfunction. Mir transporta = World of Transport and Transportation Journal. 2013. Vol. 11. № 4 (48). pp. 130–136. (In Russ.).
9. Siva Prasad Penkey, Nihal Anwar Siddiqui. A Review on Accident Pyramid and its Empirical Interpretation in Oil&Gas Industry (Upstream). International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications. 2015. Vol. 5. Iss. 1. pp. 1–3.
10. Johansen I.L., Askeland T., Dorum C. Use of «Heinrich» factor in risk assessments of ship allision in bridge design. Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference. Singapore, 2019. pp. 115–122. DOI:10.3850/978-981-11-2724-3 0857-cd
11. The unified interagency methodology of assessment of damages from emergency situations of technogenic, natural and terrorist nature, as well as the classification and recording of emergencies. Moscow: FGU VNII GOChS (FTs), 2004. (In Russ.).
12. Arkhipets N.N. Economic theory: educational and methodological complex in 2 parts. Part 2 Economics of protection against emergency situations. Minsk: KII, 2005. 134 p.
DOI: 10.24000/0409-2961-2020-11-63-68
Year: 2020
Issue num: November
Keywords : hazardous production facility risk-oriented approach efficiency assessment incident pyramid inspection and control activity proactive approach prevented damage
  • Lukyanchikov M.I.
    General Director OOO Gazprom gaznadzor, Moscow, Russia
  • Lesnykh V.V.
    vvlesnykh@gmail.com, Dr. Sci. (Eng.), Prof., Adviser to Director General OOO Gazprom gaznadzor, Moscow, Russia, Professor of the Department RUDN University, Moscow, Russia